Stuffed Mushrooms

To make one of our favorite party appetizers, we stuffed baby bella mushrooms with garlicky, herby breadcrumbs and two types of cheese. The result? The most irresistible holiday appetizer that just might disappear before your main course appears. This easy appetizer adds a bit of fancy flare to your spread, whether you're serving them at your Christmas dinner or New Year's celebration. 

First time making stuffed mushrooms? Don't sweat it—while they may look especially fancy, they're really quite easy to make. Keep on reading for all of our helpful hints on making this poppable app. 

How do I clean and prep my mushrooms?

Mushrooms usually have a ton of dirt stuck to them from growing so close to the ground, so cleaning them before cooking is crucial. Give them a quick rinse in a colander under cold running water and wipe the mushrooms with a damp paper towel to remove any remaining dirt stuck around the caps and stems. Removing the mushroom stem gives you more room for filling, but it doesn’t go to waste! The mushroom and stems get chopped up, cooked, and combined with the filling, making these stuffed beauties extra hearty. 

Do I have to use baby bella (cremini) mushrooms?

No, feel free to switch it up! This recipe also works well with white button mushrooms, or you can go larger with portobello mushroom caps instead.

Do I have to use parmesan cheese?

Nope! Parmesan is a classic choice for stuffed mushrooms, but this recipe is easily adaptable to your favorite cheese. Try gruyere, fontina, or even feta to make these suit your taste.

Can these be made ahead?

Definitely, unbaked stuffed mushrooms keep well in the freezer for up to three months. Freeze them in a flat layer, then transfer them to a resealable freezer-safe bag for easy storage. When you're ready for them, bake them frozen, but make sure to add on a bit longer of a cooking time! 

Have you made these yet? Let us know how it went in the comments below!